If you’ve been using Broadly — or you’re looking at it and hesitating — you’re not alone. Broadly has been a familiar name in the home service space for years, offering review management, webchat, and customer messaging for HVAC companies, plumbers, electricians, and other trades.
But a lot has changed since Vendasta acquired Broadly in 2023. The product roadmap has slowed. Pricing hasn’t come down. And if you spend ten minutes on Trustpilot or the BBB, you’ll find a growing list of service business owners frustrated with billing issues, long contracts, and a product that hasn’t kept up.
Here’s the truth: paying $299 to $699 per month for review requests and a webchat widget doesn’t make sense anymore. Not when there are tools that do more for a fraction of the price.
Let’s look at the best alternatives.
Before we get into alternatives, it’s worth understanding what’s pushing people away from Broadly in the first place. These are the complaints that come up over and over:
The price is hard to justify. Broadly’s plans start at $299/mo and go up to $699/mo for their premium tier. On top of that, there’s a $350 setup fee. For a small plumbing company or a two-truck HVAC operation, that’s a significant line item for a tool that mostly sends review requests.
12-month contracts with difficult cancellation. Broadly requires annual commitments. If you decide it’s not working after three months, you’re still paying for nine more. Multiple BBB complaints mention billing continuing after cancellation attempts.
The Vendasta acquisition changed things. When Vendasta acquired Broadly in 2023, many customers noticed changes in support responsiveness and product development. New features have been sparse. The tool feels more like a legacy product being maintained than a product being actively improved.
No problem detection or retention tools. This is the biggest gap. Broadly helps you ask for reviews and respond to messages. But it does nothing to help you catch unhappy customers before they leave a bad review, and nothing to bring past customers back for repeat service. For service businesses where repeat revenue is the foundation of profitability, that’s a major missing piece.
Price: $65/mo Standard, $100/mo Pro (annual: $55/mo and $85/mo) Contract: None. Month-to-month. Free trial: 14 days, no credit card required.
VisibleFeedback was built specifically for service businesses — HVAC, plumbing, pest control, cleaning, and electrical companies. It takes a fundamentally different approach than Broadly.
Instead of jumping straight to “leave us a review,” VisibleFeedback first asks the customer how the job went. If the customer is happy, they get guided toward leaving a Google review. If something went wrong, you find out privately — in your inbox, the same day — before it ever becomes a public complaint.
That alone makes it worth the switch. But VisibleFeedback also includes retention reminders that Broadly doesn’t offer at all. It tracks when customers are due for seasonal maintenance, filter changes, annual inspections, and other recurring services. Then it sends automated reminders that bring them back. For HVAC companies, that means more tune-up appointments. For pest control, that means fewer lapsed quarterly contracts. For plumbers, that means the customer calls you for the next problem instead of Googling someone else.
What VisibleFeedback does that Broadly doesn’t:
Where Broadly still has an edge:
The bottom line: At $65/mo with no contract vs. $299-$699/mo with a 12-month lock-in, VisibleFeedback gives you more functionality for roughly 80% less money. If you care about keeping customers — not just collecting reviews — this is the strongest alternative on the list.
Price: $75/mo (Reviews plan), $125/mo (Pro plan) Contract: None. Free trial: 14 days, no credit card.
NiceJob is a well-built review generation platform. It’s good at what it does: after each job, it sends your customer a review request via email and SMS, making it as easy as possible for them to leave a Google or Facebook review. They claim to have helped businesses collect over 1.7 million reviews, and the numbers back that up.
If your only goal is more 5-star reviews, NiceJob delivers. The review request flow is polished, the reminders are well-timed, and the dashboard is clean.
The gap: NiceJob doesn’t check in with customers before asking for reviews. Every customer gets the same flow — whether the job went perfectly or the AC started making noise two days later. There’s no private feedback step, no problem detection, and no retention reminders. It’s a review machine, not a customer retention tool.
Best for: Businesses that already have strong retention and just need help collecting more reviews. If you’re losing customers to competitors and don’t know why, NiceJob won’t fix that.
Price: $39/mo add-on to existing Jobber subscription Contract: Tied to your Jobber subscription terms. Free trial: Included in Jobber trial.
If you’re already using Jobber for scheduling and invoicing, their Marketing Suite add-on is worth a look. It pulls customer data directly from your Jobber account and lets you send review requests, email campaigns, and automated follow-ups without switching between platforms.
The integration is the selling point. Your job completion data flows directly into marketing triggers, so review requests go out at the right time without any manual work.
The gap: Jobber’s marketing tools are basic compared to dedicated platforms. The review request flow is straightforward but not as refined as NiceJob’s. There’s no problem detection. Retention reminders are limited to what you set up manually through email campaigns. And if you don’t use Jobber for scheduling, this option doesn’t exist for you.
Best for: Businesses that already run their operations on Jobber and want “good enough” marketing without adding another vendor. If marketing and customer retention are top priorities, a dedicated tool will outperform this add-on.
Price: $289/mo and up (custom pricing for larger businesses) Contract: Typically 12 months. Free trial: Demo only.
Podium is a heavyweight. It offers review management, webchat, text-based payments, and a unified inbox for customer messages across channels. For larger service businesses with multiple locations or high message volume, Podium’s feature set is genuinely impressive.
The platform is well-built and the text-to-pay feature is something smaller tools don’t offer. If you have a front office team that manages customer communication all day, Podium gives them a single place to do it.
The gap: Podium’s pricing puts it in the same tier as Broadly — and in some cases higher. The contracts are typically annual. And like Broadly, Podium is designed around communication and reviews, not around detecting problems or driving repeat business. You’re paying enterprise prices for what is essentially a fancy messaging and review platform.
Best for: Multi-location service businesses with 10+ employees that need a unified communication platform and have the budget to support it.
| Feature | VisibleFeedback | NiceJob | Jobber Marketing | Podium | Broadly |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $65/mo | $75/mo | $39/mo add-on | $289/mo | $299/mo |
| Setup fee | None | None | None | Varies | $350 |
| Contract required | No | No | Tied to Jobber | 12 months | 12 months |
| Problem detection | Yes | No | No | No | No |
| Retention reminders | Yes | No | Limited | No | No |
| Review automation | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| SMS follow-up | Pro plan | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | 14 days | 14 days | With Jobber trial | Demo only | Demo only |
The right tool depends on what problem you’re trying to solve.
Choose VisibleFeedback if you want to stop losing customers to problems you never heard about, bring past customers back for repeat service, and save $200-$600/mo compared to Broadly. It’s the only tool on this list that combines problem detection, review automation, and retention reminders in one platform at a price that makes sense for a small service business.
Choose NiceJob if your business is running well, customers are generally happy, and you just need more Google reviews. It’s a focused tool that does one thing well.
Choose Jobber Marketing Suite if you already use Jobber and want to add basic marketing without another vendor. Don’t expect it to compete with dedicated tools.
Choose Podium if you’re a larger operation that needs unified messaging, text payments, and review management, and you have the budget for a premium platform.
No. Broadly was acquired by Vendasta in 2023 and continues to operate. However, many users have reported slower product development and support since the acquisition. The tool is still functional, but whether it’s still the best value for service businesses is a fair question.
Broadly typically requires 12-month commitments. Early cancellation may involve paying out the remaining contract balance. Check your specific agreement and contact their support team for cancellation terms. Multiple BBB complaints mention difficulty canceling, so document everything in writing.
Jobber Marketing Suite at $39/mo is the cheapest option, but it requires an existing Jobber subscription. As a standalone tool, VisibleFeedback at $65/mo is the most affordable full-featured alternative, offering problem detection, retention reminders, and review automation with no contracts.
Yes. VisibleFeedback automates review requests after every job — but with an important difference. It checks customer satisfaction first. Happy customers get guided to Google. Unhappy customers get routed to you privately. You get more reviews and fewer public complaints.
VisibleFeedback is purpose-built for service businesses including HVAC. The retention reminder feature is particularly valuable for HVAC companies because it automates seasonal maintenance reminders — spring tune-ups, fall check-ups, filter replacements — that drive repeat revenue throughout the year.
No. Most of these tools, including VisibleFeedback, offer free trials that let you test the platform alongside your current setup. You can run both in parallel for two weeks before making the switch.
Broadly was a reasonable choice three or four years ago. But at $299-$699/mo with 12-month contracts and no problem detection or retention features, it’s hard to recommend in 2026 — especially when tools like VisibleFeedback offer more functionality at $65/mo with no strings attached.
If you run an HVAC, plumbing, pest control, cleaning, or electrical business and you’re paying for Broadly (or thinking about it), take 14 days and try VisibleFeedback for free. No credit card. No contract. Just see if catching problems early and keeping customers coming back is worth more to your business than what you’re paying now.
You can start a free trial at VisibleFeedback.com.
Text or email clients after every job. Catch issues early, recover unhappy clients fast, and drive repeat work with smart reminders.
Austin Spaeth is the founder of VisibleFeedback, a tool that helps service companies automate post-job follow-ups, catch issues early, and drive repeat work with smart reminders. With a background in software development and a focus on practical customer retention systems, Austin built VisibleFeedback to make it easy to text or email customers after every job, route problems to the right person, and keep relationships strong without awkward outreach. When he’s not building new features or writing playbooks for service businesses, he’s wrangling his six kids or sneaking in a beach day.
Whether you’re dealing with callbacks, unhappy customers, or low repeat work, we’ll help you tighten the follow up loop.
No credit card required.
